Discussion about this post

User's avatar
jeff klugman's avatar

most clinical depression is chronic, like most adult diseases. we get the wrong idea when we are little kids or have little kids. we think illnesses are like strep throat or middle ear infections: take the meds 5-10 days and you're done.

adult diseases like high blood pressure, diabetes, cardiovasular disease, are chronic and require chronic treatment. if you have a single episode of clinical depression you might get off antidepressants and stay off them. once you've had 3 episodes, accept that it's chronic and stay on the meds that helped you. 2 episodes: depends on how severe, how quick in onset, how dangerous, personal preference.

sometimes i tell people that part of my job as a psychiatrist is telling if they're depressed [clinically] or just miserable. don't mistake situational suffering for clinical depression. the former might trigger the latter, however, so it might take a professional to really tell the difference.

unipolar depression is more likely accompanied by diminished or disturbed sleep, while bipolar depression often has excessive sleep. bipolar mixed states - excess energy usually in the form of irritability, agitation, raciness, and diminished sleep accompanied by depressed mood, is really uncomfortable and really dangerous. this is the state that is most likely to lead to suicide.

if you can exercise yourself to a better mood, good for you. but there's no shame in getting checked out by someone who understands these things. getting checked out doesn't commit you to meds or treatment of any kind. so don't make a big deal of getting checked out if you're suffering. maybe you're just miserable.

Expand full comment
BH's avatar

This is good stuff - practical, helpful, and written with your usual clarity and style.

Expand full comment
6 more comments...

No posts